If marriage is redefined to include same-sex couples, either by the Supreme Court,
or another way, many people think marriage will collapse as an institution. They
point to the Netherlands, where gay marriage has been legal for 12 years and where
marriage holds little relevance to the way people live. Others believe that in the U.S.,
where the Church is more vibrant, marriage will still be normative. Perhaps, but
legal same sex marriage is going to result in the catastrophic loss of the ability of the
church….to be the church.
Remember Eugene Robinson, the Episcopalian minister from New Hampshire who
was the first openly homosexual priest to be elected Bishop? This event ripped
apart Anglicanism. Bishop Robinson is now retired from the church and working
as Senior Fellow — guess where — at the far left Center for American Progress.
He wrote a column in celebration of what he sees as progress on the same-sex
marriage front. The piece was published in the Washington Post during Holy Week,
the same week the Supreme Court heard oral arguments in the cases challenging
laws protecting marriage as it’s traditionally defined. In it, he warns his fellow gay
activists, “Whatever the rulings of the Supreme Court in June, there will be much
work to do, requiring of us both patience and tenacity. There are places where it is
still legal to fire someone simply for being gay; there remain harsh health disparities
for our community; and because of hateful rhetoric from religious leaders and other
opinion makers, we still have LGBT people jumping off bridges.”
We have to ask: does this “work” that needs to be done include forcing employers,
even religious employers, to employ open homosexuals? Kind of like the HHS
mandate under ObamaCare with its terrible implications for religious activity?
And, does this “hateful rhetoric from religious leaders,” that’s supposedly
responsible for gay people’s suicides, include articulating the biblical position on
homosexuality? On marriage? What’s the fix? Somehow punishing this speech?
Believing saint, it’s bad enough that the highest court in the land is even considering
changing marriage to something it’s not, to something that’s characterized by a
complete repudiation of God’s plan and natural law. But, it won’t stop there. The
Supreme Court hasn’t even ruled yet and they’re already talking about punishing
those who disagree, especially “religious leaders” and sidelining religiously
motivated good works. Think of Catholic Charities who, in Massachusetts, California,
and DC had to adopt out kids to gay couples or close their doors. They closed their
doors.
If the country finds it must treat same-sex marriage as true marriage as a matter
of human rights or equality, seeing it differently will be categorized as irrational
bigotry. The lower court’s federal judge in the Proposition 8 case has already said as
much. National same-sex marriage will bring a terrible loss of religious freedom for
those who affirm God’s view of marriage.